October 29, 2008

Raj and hate politics in India

Two different Raj:
One loses life for a cause, the other takes lives for it.

The news of a Bihari youth being shot dead in Mumbai on Monday has baffled many. Rahul Raj, 23, took the passengers of a bus hostage and demanded to meet Mumbai’s police commissioner and wanted to kill Raj Thackeray. However, the cause that drove this unemployed youth, who had come to Mumbai to seek a job, to take such a desperate means to send a political message has forced politicians to make a call to ban MNS and punish others.

“According to those who knew Rahul, the case was particularly tragic because he was motivated by anger over MNS activists targeting Bihari youth looking for employment in Mumbai; and the attack on those appearing for a Railway Recruitment Board Examination on Oct. 19 deeply disturbed him.”

— The Hindu, Oct. 30
Lack of strong control body

Raj Thackeray is likely to exploit the tragedy to fuel more hostility and hate politics for his ‘matribhoomi’ campaign. India must devise a strong mechanism to deal with the likes of Raj Thackeray and groups like MNS and Shiv Sena that espouses violence and hatred to fulfill their political goals. The regional chauvinism weakens nationalism and its core social values. What angers me if the sad fact that people like Thackerays have blind followers who believe their criminal activities are just and acceptable. The state government has failed to stop them and the center is yet to step in to control the wildfire of violence that has already tarnished the Congress-led rule recently and can seriously damage their chances of winning in the upcoming elections.

Meeting local demands

Issuing a ban on MNS alone cannot solve the growing crisis. The state governments should be directed by the center to make necessary laws to protect Indian citizens of any origin, religion or state. The center must come up with tough laws to control the activities of groups like MNS. The MNS ‘campaign’ has now cost another life and this could be only the beginning unless national interest becomes the first priority, not the politics. Politicians do use hunger and poverty as their pass to power. Marathis want employment and security. The Maharastra government has no option than to introduce employment and educational programmes to cater to the needs of the local people.

Goonda raj

Rai Thackeray wants his ‘goonda raj’ to succeed his uncle. Such malevolence is in his blood. I saw a photograph the other day in which two women were holding ‘puja thalis’ to welcome Raj back home from the prison. It made me wonder what kind of lives these women would have under a beast like him. Forget the paradoxes about Raj Thackarey, what he’s done is enough to know what he is — a beast. Thackeray’s terror tactics in the name of politics is unacceptable. It can damage the youth of India and force them to terrorism — the same path Rahul forced himself on.

A cause of great concern

"From what I could gather from his educational and family background and the incident, the boy (Rahul Raj) was definitely mentally disturbed. In this atmosphere of political and financial instability, the boy must feel threatened if jobless and insecure. Unfortunately these kinds of political campaigns fuel latent psychotic episodes. It probably wouldn’t have occurred if he wasn’t influenced by these political campaigns,” said Dr Kersi Chadva, psychiatrist at Hinduja Hospital.

“He fired two bullets on the ground and didn’t mean real harm. Writing messages, throwing chits, is definitely not the work of a criminal mind. He was just unfortunate young boy caught in a turmoil,” said Dr Harish Shetty, psychiatrist at Hiranandani Hospital.

- Hindustan Times, Oct. 28

Rahul embodies the frustration and the rage of his age and people. The problem is a serious one and needs an urgent cure. And strict action against the guilty and ban on MNS and the likes and formulation of strict laws against such groups are the only remedy in sight. Of course, it will take time but the government has to initiate the action. For now, New Delhi must do everything to protect its citizens in Maharastra.

The MNS is succeeding in its terror campaign, Bihar has already caught the fire, and the political thugs want to set the country on fire. There’s no way to stop them but the center to step in and rein the MNS hoodlums.

A tragic end


I can’t express my rage in violent means. Kathmandu Speaks wanted to pay a tribute to the young man who didn’t forget his decency until his death:

“When I first saw him, I never thought he would do something like this. He looked a pretty decent fellow. At one point, after he took us hostage, he grabbed my wife by the arm and tried to drag her towards the window. However, when he saw it was a woman, he actually apologised to her and let her return to her seat.”

— The Asian Age, Oct 28.

Read More...

October 27, 2008

Twenty’s Troubles

Salik Shah
Narcissist! Of course.

On life and love at twenty

Is there a way to know if it’s real or not? The troubles I face at twenty aren’t new but it’s so difficult to get over and start all over again. It’s funny, really very funny though. This coming-of-age thingo. I don’t want to be vague, so let’s talk about François Truffaut’s short Antoine and Colette from the 1962 anthology collection Love at Twenty. Antoine’s just foolin’ around. Just growing up. But winning love matters a lot, and we have ego clashes all the time and it really hurts at times. But it’s fine. “Just enjoy.”

OKAY I won’t think much about it again.

FANS: With Srijoy

“When I was twenty, I used to feel the same way. But the phase passes on,” Srijoy said about my obsession with Led Zeppelin. Robert Plant's youthful voice of the 70s and their music, their songs…. Blame it on my youth, right now it’s Thin Lizzy. I did sing Knocking on Heaven’s Doors, the kids’ stuff you know, recently before the folks during one of our office parties. I asked Natasha to join me for the song. She teaches music in some school for ‘kids’ and will soon work with those big names, Bhuwan dai said.

Well, I didn’t expect you to laugh my love when I told you I was writing a song for a guy! lol Did jot a song for Sai yesterday. He was buggin’ me for a long time. He’s a cool bassist. I wish I could be around for some time and play you know.

And if I return home soon, Apurwa, we can shoot that too.

All the normal things a regular guy could think of!

And I’m working on a script about a guy who’s just picked up a guitar and is growing up. He meets a girl, there’s first love, that first sex, first heartbreak, and so many emotions he never thought ever existed. There’s also music, how his music changes and his emotions influence it and how it attains a certain maturity with his age. I’m really serious about the project. I might land in Mumbai next year! lol

I hope I don’t overdo it. I really want to be sensible with people I really care. Want ‘em to be happy all the time. Call it love, but I don’t care. (lol) But I don’t want to look pathetic and say something stupid! Is that clear?

Antoine and Colette is here on youtube: Part I, Part II and Part III. You oughtta watch this funny short ‘Fleeting’ to know why I am still not sure if we’re for real this time. But I’m in love! Rolf!!!! So many ‘lol’s and a ‘Rolf’ prove it. My girl’s an absolute delight.

Read More...

October 25, 2008

Ma Sansar Jitney Aant Gardai Chhu

Read More...

October 24, 2008

Barack Obama for President

Upon the endorsement of Barack Obama by The New York Times, I felt obliged to write back last night:

Your endorsement should have come earlier.
Barack Obama has already improved the image of the United States across the world. He's here for change and even I believe him. Obama will be the obvious choice for those who know problems that America faces today call for an end to Mr. Bush’s legacy. I really think Mr. Bush should be tried for the wartime crime the U.S. and its allied troops have committed in Afghanistan, Iraq and elsewhere.
The world is waiting for the justice to be done.

— Salik Shah, Kathmandu (link)
This post is just an update and a record.
There are already over 1700 comments!

Read More...

October 16, 2008

Eraserhead (1977)

Jack Nance as Henry Spencer in Eraserhead

A young David Lynch never divulged details about the making of his films. Lynch has also maintained and fed mysteries about his debut film Eraserhead (1977). David Foster Wallace was talking about David Lynch's influence during one of his interviews with Charlie Rose and that's how I learned about this filmmaker. Wallace was talking about Blue Velvet (1986), I thought I should start with David Lynch's ‘most spiritual’ cinematic work — a horror film, Eraserhead, which Lynch wrote during his first year at a film school.

I saw Eraserhead last week but am still humming ‘In Heaven Everything Is Fine’. Actually, this is the only thing I'd like to recall from the movie. Lynch introduces the ultimate comic relief with this strain but not in less disturbing way. The chipmunk-cheek woman could remind many the women they hate but have been forced to live with no end in sight. If you're talking about aesthetics, the song is beautiful but how many could possibly find aesthetics beautiful?

The Lady in the Radiator, Eraserhead On the set of Eraserhead, David Lynch makes up Laurel Near as the Lady in the Radiator (1977)/Galen Young

Lynch's alien baby brought chill running down my spine. This whining baby mocks its father Henry while he desperately seeks the seductress across the hall. What follows is sickening distorted human desire that culminates Eraserhead into a cult classic. How can one be so true to his thoughts? But artists do propel minor emotions to an exaggerated proportion: a dining scene where a nervous Henry is sitting next to his girlfriend’s father across the cooked chicken that spurts dark liquid and wiggles ‘obscenely’ on its plate. All this reminds the tension one faces at the house of a girlfriend who has bore a deformed ‘baby’ prematurely.

Eraserhead seems to have multiple climaxes which make it obvious that Lynch was confronted with far too many ideas and faced dilemma to give a conclusive end to his film which took five of his productive years mainly due to inadequate funding. And fund is something every new director lacks! Lynch’s ‘Philadelphia Story’ and the period in-between the making of Eraserhead is more ghastly.

The film lacks coherence and its symbolic ‘spiritualism’ could be out of normal heads unless you’re on drugs. Here, another fictional spiritual classic, Bible, could be of some help. Brave hearts can sit and enjoy the thrill while neurotics might as well relate to Lynch’s ‘beautiful’ depiction of the life spent in seclusion and constant fear. Lynch introduces bizarre ideas in a brilliant fashion that scares less and seduces more. But Eraserhead isn’t a must-watch unless you’re a movie freak and find black and white stock really appealing.

Links:
Wikipedia
NYT Review

Here are the youtube links to part I and II of a short on Eraserhead.

Read More...

Recent News, Analysis and Opinions